Article · Clinical supervision

Choosing a Clinical Supervisor: A Guide for RP(Q)s and Clinicians New to Private Practice

By Karen Hurley, MSW, RP, RSW, RMFT

When therapists come to me looking for a supervisor, the question underneath their questions is almost always the same: will I feel safe enough to be myself here? Will I be able to bring my mistakes, my uncertainty and my feelings about my clients into the room without being judged?

Whether you are an RP (Qualifying) working toward full registration with CRPO, or a social worker setting up a private practice and seeking supervision for the first time, you are still building your practice and your confidence.

More than a licensing requirement

Registration requirements bring many therapists to supervision. What keeps them there, and what makes the hours worthwhile, is the relationship. In good supervision, you feel supported and clinically challenged at the same time. You are encouraged to become the competent, confident and reflective clinician you are meant to be.

I have come to see support and challenge as partners. When a clinician feels genuinely supported, it becomes possible to hear a challenge and to look honestly at their work, including a session that didn't go well or a pattern they hadn't noticed. A thoughtful challenge, offered within that support, is often where the most meaningful growth begins.

Paying attention to how you leave

Over the years, I have come to trust one simple measure: notice how you feel at the end of a supervision session. A good supervisory relationship tends to leave you steadier and more confident, more curious about your clients, and more willing to take thoughtful clinical risks. Mistakes become part of learning, something you can bring into the room and explore together. Most of all, you feel supported in your growth, and the worry about being evaluated begins to fade.

If supervision often leaves you feeling anxious, small or alone with your cases, that is worth paying attention to. It may be a sign to look for a different fit.

What to look for in a supervisor

Supervision carries a natural power dynamic, and a good supervisor handles it with care. A certain humbleness matters here. None of us has all the answers, and a supervisor who is open to learning, including from the people they supervise, models the kind of curiosity we hope to bring to our clients.

Look for someone who welcomes vulnerability. Some of the most important material in supervision is personal: the client who frightens you, the session that stirred up your own history, the moment you doubted whether you belong in this work. These are the places where real learning happens, and they deserve to be met with understanding.

Look, too, for collaboration alongside honest feedback. Good supervision is a shared inquiry. It also includes constructive feedback, offered clearly and kindly, so you can see your work from a new angle.

Theoretical orientation is part of the fit as well. You and your supervisor do not need to share an identical approach, and there is real value in being introduced to new ways of thinking. Still, some alignment in your philosophy of therapy, and in the values you bring to the work, makes the conversation richer and helps you feel understood.

Questions worth asking in a first conversation

A first conversation with a potential supervisor is a chance to sense the fit for yourself. You might ask:

  • How would you describe your theoretical orientation, and how does it shape your supervision?
  • What happens in supervision when I make a mistake with a client?
  • How do you offer feedback?
  • Will we explore my own reactions to clients, or focus mainly on case management?
  • How do you support supervisees who are working toward full registration?

Pay attention to how the answers feel as well as what they say. You will often learn as much from the tone of the conversation as from its content.

How I approach supervision

Over more than thirty years of practice, and many years of supervising and mentoring clinicians, I have come to see supervision as one of the most meaningful parts of my work. Many of the therapists I supervise have told me they value the openness and gentleness they find in our sessions, and that the more vulnerable and intimate details of their experience are met with understanding and support.

I encourage independent thinking and welcome vulnerability, and I work collaboratively while offering constructive feedback, because I believe you deserve a place that is both safe and honest.

I think of one supervisee who came to me focused almost entirely on the here and now. She offered her clients practical tools and strategies, yet several of them remained stuck. Over time, she became willing to look at her own countertransference and to attend to the more latent feelings in the room, feelings that often grew out of childhood wounds and a lack of emotional attunement. As she did, she began to recognize the patterns and understand her clients far more deeply. There was more beneath the surface than first met the eye, and as her insight grew, so did her confidence.

I offer both individual and dyad supervision. In individual supervision, there is more room to explore personal material, such as the feelings a client stirs in you or the moments that touch your own history. In a dyad, two clinicians meet together with me. Supervisees often find that hearing a peer's cases and reflections broadens their thinking, eases the sense of isolation, and creates a shared space for learning. Some clinicians begin in one format and move to the other as their needs change.

If you are looking for a supervisor

I am a qualified clinical supervisor for Registered Psychotherapists (Qualifying) with CRPO, and I also supervise social workers and other clinicians building their private practices, as well as experienced therapists seeking consultation. I offer individual and dyad supervision online across Ontario. If you are searching for the right fit, I would be glad to talk with you. Learn more about clinical supervision.

You may also like my article Holding Space for the Healers: Why Clinical Supervision Matters, on the value of supervision at every stage of a career.

Get in touch

Interested in supervision?

Appointments are available Monday to Saturday, daytime and evening, by secure video.

Send us a message

Or call or text 416-723-9364